# EU court adviser says a service that takes personal data cannot be called "free"

> An EU Advocate General said on 19 November 2026 that personal data counts as payment. The Facebook case could change "free" claims in ads. What it is, what to do.
- **Author**: Marxx
- **Published**: 2026-11-22
- **Category**: Meta
- **URL**: https://marxx.ai/library-news/eu-adviser-facebook-free-claim-personal-data-november-19

---

An adviser to the EU's top court said on **19 November 2026** that a service which makes you hand over personal data cannot call itself "free" under EU consumer law. The opinion is not binding, and no judge has ruled yet.

## What we know

- **Reported by PPC Land on 22 November 2026,** which read the opinion: Advocate General Laila Medina advised the Court of Justice of the EU in case C-643/25.
- **The case:** a German consumer group, the vzbv, sued Meta over a February 2015 sign-up line, "Facebook ist und bleibt kostenlos" (Facebook is and remains free). Two Berlin courts dismissed the claim. Germany's Federal Court of Justice then asked the EU court what "cost" means.
- **The advice:** the word "cost" covers handing over personal data and agreeing to its commercial use, unless the data only runs the service or meets a legal duty.
- **Not final:** the judges have only started to deliberate. Germany's court decides the case itself after they rule.
- **Wider reach:** the rule is on the EU blacklist of unfair practices and applies to any business that sells to consumers in the EU.

| Item | Status |
|---|---|
| Opinion given | 19 November 2026 |
| Binding on the court | No |
| Final ruling | Not yet |
| Applies to | Any trader selling to EU consumers |

## What it means for your ad account

Nothing changes in your account today. If the court agrees, any "free" claim in your ads or landing pages could break an EU rule when the offer needs sign-up data that you use for marketing. That matters if you sell to Gulf or Indian buyers and also to the EU.

Sign-up forms that feed your [Meta Pixel](/glossary/meta-pixel) or [Conversions API](/glossary/conversions-api) data are the place to look first.

## What to do this week

1. **List every ad and page** that says "free" (free trial, free sample, free app, free report).
2. **Mark those that need an email or phone number** before the buyer gets the item.
3. **Check your consent wording** against [Consent Mode v2](/glossary/consent-mode-v2) if you run EU traffic.
4. **Ask a lawyer** before you change copy. This page is not legal advice.
5. **Wait for the court's ruling** before you pull live ads.

## FAQ

### Is "free" now banned in EU ads?

No. This is an adviser's opinion. The court has not ruled.

### Does this only affect Meta?

No. The blacklist rule covers any trader selling to EU consumers, according to PPC Land's reading of the opinion.

### When will the court decide?

No date is public. We did not find one on the day we checked.

---
- [More Meta articles](https://marxx.ai/library-news/category/meta)
- [All articles](https://marxx.ai/library-news)